The modern classic motorcycle scene is booming, and no category captures the imagination quite like the scrambler. These bikes blend vintage cool with modern performance, offering a do-it-all attitude with undeniable style. In this competitive arena, two major contenders stand out: the Italian-designed Benelli Leoncino 800 and the iconic British Triumph Scrambler 900.
While they both target the same rider, they do so with vastly different philosophies. One is a value-packed modern machine wrapped in retro clothing, while the other is the very definition of authentic heritage. So, which one is right for you? Let's break it down.
Design and Heritage: Italian Flair vs. British Grit
Triumph Scrambler 900:
When you picture a modern scrambler, you’re likely picturing the Triumph. As the torchbearer for the genre, the Scrambler 900 exudes authenticity. Its design is a direct evolution of the classic Bonneville, complete with a teardrop tank, bench seat, and the signature high-mounted twin exhaust. It’s a timeless look that doesn't scream for attention but earns it with its clean lines and undeniable heritage. This is the original recipe, refined for the modern era.
Benelli Leoncino 800:
The Leoncino 800—Italian for "little lion"—takes a different approach. While it has scrambler DNA, its design is more neo-retro and muscular. The lines are sharper, the steel trellis frame is proudly on display, and the overall stance is more aggressive and contemporary. The charming little lion ornament on the front fender is a nod to Benelli's storied past, but the bike feels very much of the present. It’s less of a tribute and more of a modern interpretation of the scrambler theme.
The Heart of the Matter: Engine and Performance
Benelli Leoncino 800:
At the core of the Leoncino is a 754cc liquid-cooled parallel-twin engine. This motor is all about lively, modern performance. It's more rev-happy than the Triumph, delivering a spirited punch in the mid-to-high RPM range. It feels eager and energetic, making it a joy on twisty backroads. The power delivery is more akin to a modern naked bike, offering a ride that is engaging and exciting.
Triumph Scrambler 900:
Triumph’s 900cc “High Torque” parallel-twin is legendary for a reason. As the name suggests, this engine is all about low-end grunt. The power is available instantly, right off the line, making it incredibly user-friendly and satisfying for city riding and relaxed cruising. The 270-degree crank angle gives it a characterful V-twin-like rumble that is both iconic and deeply satisfying. It’s not about chasing high RPMs; it's about a rich, soulful, and accessible riding experience.
Hardware and Technology: Spec-Sheet Hero vs. Proven Performer
This is where the two bikes diverge most significantly.
Benelli Leoncino 800:
On paper, the Benelli is a clear winner in the hardware department. It comes equipped with high-spec components that you’d typically find on more expensive bikes. This includes fully adjustable 50mm Marzocchi front forks, a rear monoshock with preload and rebound adjustment, and powerful Brembo brakes. To top it off, it features a beautiful, full-color TFT display that feels thoroughly modern.
Triumph Scrambler 900:
The Triumph opts for a more traditional, function-over-flash setup. The suspension, typically from KYB, is simpler and often only offers preload adjustment at the rear. The braking is handled by a capable single Brembo caliper up front. While it lacks the adjustability of the Benelli, the components are well-sorted and provide a predictable, confidence-inspiring ride for its intended purpose. Technologically, it features a classic analogue speedometer with an integrated LCD screen, but it has a key advantage: selectable ride modes (Road, Rain, and Off-Road), which add a significant layer of versatility.
The Verdict: Which Scrambler is for You?
Choosing between these two excellent machines comes down to your priorities. There is no single "better" bike, only the one that is better for you.
You should choose the Benelli Leoncino 800 if:
You should choose the Triumph Scrambler 900 if:
In essence, the Leoncino 800 is a fantastic modern motorcycle that offers incredible performance and features for its price, all wrapped in a stylish scrambler package. The Triumph Scrambler 900, on the other hand, is an experience. It’s a purchase made with the heart, offering an authentic connection to the history of motorcycling itself.
